Camera modules often encounter some image defects during the imaging process,often broadly termed as camera artifacting, is crucial. Among the most commonly confused are rolling shutter artifacts and motion blur. While both can lead to an unclear or distorted appearance, they stem from fundamentally different mechanisms within the camera.
To truly grasp their distinctions, we first need to understand what is shutter in camera and how different shutter types operate.This article will gradually explain these phenomena,clarify their causes, and explain how to differentiate between them, particularly when considering a rolling shutter vs global shutter camera system.At the same time, after this article's explanation, it is clear that the misconception that global shutter cameras can eliminate both rolling shutter artifacts and motion blur.
What is a Shutter in a Camera?
At its most basic, the shutter in a camera is a mechanism that controls the duration for which the image sensor is exposed to light. This "exposure time" or "shutter speed" determines how much light reaches the sensor and ultimately, how bright the image is.
Historically, cameras used a physical, mechanical shutter that would open and close. Modern digital cameras, especially those with CMOS sensors, often rely on an "electronic shutter." The way this electronic shutter operates defines whether the camera has a rolling shutter or a global shutter.
- Rolling Shutter: The most common type in modern cameras. With a rolling shutter, the sensor's pixels are exposed sequentially, row by row, from top to bottom. This means the top row of pixels starts and finishes exposure slightly before the bottom row.
- Global Shutter: In contrast, a global shutter exposes all pixels on the sensor simultaneously, like a traditional mechanical shutter. All pixels start and finish their exposure at precisely the same moment.
For a deeper dive into these shutter types, read our articles on What is Rolling Shutter? Understanding Motion Distortion in Camera Modules and What is Global Shutter? How It Works and Why It Matters?.
Understanding Rolling Shutter Artifacts
Rolling shutter artifacts are camera artifacting that occur specifically due to the sequential exposure process of a rolling shutter sensor. When either the subject or the camera is moving very rapidly during the brief time it takes to scan all the rows, different parts of the scene are captured at slightly different moments in time. This temporal offset across the image leads to unique distortions.
Causes:
- Fast-moving objects: The object moves significantly during the sensor's scan time.
- Camera vibration/movement: The camera itself moves or vibrates rapidly.
Typical Appearances of Rolling Shutter Artifacts:
- Skew : Vertical lines appear to lean diagonally. Imagine photographing a tall building while panning rapidly; it might look like it's leaning.
- Wobble/Jello effect : Rapid vibrations (e.g., from a drone) can make the image appear to wobble or shimmer, especially noticeable on straight lines.
- Partial exposure/Tear: Extremely fast-moving objects (like a propeller or a golf club swing) might appear bent, stretched, or even disappear in parts, as different sections are captured at different points in their motion cycle.
- Exposure banding: Flickering artificial lights (like fluorescent lights) can cause bands of varying brightness across the image because the light source's flicker cycle is out of sync with the sensor's scanning.
Understanding Motion Blur
Motion blur, unlike rolling shutter artifacts, is a universal phenomenon in photography and is not specific to the type of shutter. It occurs when a subject moves, or the camera moves, during the entire exposure time (shutter speed) of the image capture. Essentially, the subject's image gets smeared or stretched across multiple pixels as it moves across the sensor while the shutter is open.
Causes:
- Slow shutter speed: The sensor is exposed to light for a relatively long duration.
- Fast subject motion: The object moves significantly within the exposure window.
- Camera movement/shake: The camera itself moves during the exposure.
Typical Appearances of Motion Blur:
- Streaking/Smearing: Objects appear streaky or smeared along the direction of motion. A car moving fast might have a blurred background or blurred wheels, while the rest of the image is sharp.
- General softness: If the camera shakes, the entire image might appear uniformly blurry or soft.
- Directional blur: The blur has a distinct direction, reflecting the path of motion.
Rolling Shutter Artifacts vs. Motion Blur: What are the Differences?
While both lead to image degradation and can sometimes appear together, rolling shutter artifacts and motion blur are distinct phenomena with different root causes and visual characteristics.
| Feature | Rolling Shutter Artifacts | Motion Blur |
|---|---|---|
| Fundamental Cause | Sequential (row-by-row) exposure during rapid motion | Subject or camera movement during the exposure time |
| Shutter Type | Occurs only with rolling shutter sensors | Occurs with any shutter type (rolling, global, mechanical) |
| Visual Appearance | Skew, wobble, jello effect, partial exposures, banding | Streaking, smearing, general softness, directional blur |
| Impact on Shape | Distorts the shape of objects (e.g., bending, skewing) | Blurs the edges and details of objects along the path of motion |
| Prevention/Mitigation | Use a global shutter camera; reduce motion speed; stabilize camera | Use a faster shutter speed; stabilize camera/subject; increase light |
| Independence | Can occur even with fast shutter speeds if motion is extreme | Directly tied to shutter speed and relative motion |
Key Distinction: Rolling shutter artifacts literally distort the geometry of objects because different parts of the object are captured at different points in time. Motion blur, on the other hand, smears the image of an object over time as it moves across the sensor during a single exposure.
Consider a spinning propeller:
- Rolling Shutter: Might make the propeller blades appear bent or curved, even if they are straight.
- Motion Blur: Would make the propeller blades appear as a streaky, transparent circle due to their rapid rotation during the exposure.
For a detailed comparison between these technologies for various applications, refer to: Global Shutter vs. Rolling Shutter: Which Is Better for Your Camera Module Application?
Conclusion
Understanding the differences between rolling shutter artifacts and motion blur is vital for anyone working with camera systems, from photographers and videographers to engineers designing embedded vision systems. While motion blur is a consequence of exposure time and motion, rolling shutter artifacts are specific to the sequential scanning nature of most modern CMOS sensors.
Choosing the right camera for your application-whether that involves high-speed subjects where a global shutter might be preferable, or controlling exposure time to manage motion blur-hinges on this fundamental understanding. By correctly identifying the source of camera artifacting, you can implement the appropriate solutions and capture clearer, more accurate images of our dynamic world.
Muchvision: Solving image defects with innovative technologies
As a leading camera module manufacturer in China, muchvision, with over 10 years of industry experience, has provided one solution after another for embedded vision projects in various fields. If you are currently troubled by image issues with a project, you might as well try to contact us. We believe that our professional team of engineers and innovative technology can provide you with assistance.Or you can also visit our product list.
One-stop camera module customization solution
Send us your requirements for camera modules and we will customize the best solution for you. With our premium solutions, you can enhance your products, engage your customers, and open new opportunities for the growth and success of embedded vision applications.
